Tax & ATO News Australia
Searching for tag: Federal Government
Franking Credit Proposed Changes
Politicians just cannot help mucking around with tax laws. I am not the first person to talk about this, and right now I am obviously not the only person, as the Federal Opposition’s latest thought bubble on refunding franking credits is roundly and rightly criticised.
In the interests of fairness and balance, I want to talk about another ill-thought out and retrospective proposed change which the current Federal Government is planning to make to small business concessions. But before I do that, just one quick comment in relation to the Opposition’s franking credit problem that I have not seen anyone make. Bear with me – this is a bit mathsy:
The Opposition’s proposal is that the government will stop drawing cheques to people who receive franking credits in excess of their taxable income. Practically, as has dominated the press in recent days, this targets self funded retirees who received franked dividends from companies, but do not have large taxable incomes because they are receiving tax-free superannuation pensions. The theory apparently being, well hey, they are not going to vote ALP anyway. So far, so cynical. And to someone who doesn’t understand how franking credits work, it kind of makes sense: why should the Government be sending out cheques to all of these wealthy old people?
But here’s the rub – there is absolutely zero difference to the budget bottom line whether a rebate is represented by a payment from the government or a reduction in tax payable by a tax payer. In either case, this is money that government does not have.
To give you the example, take two people: Vince a self funded retiree with a self managed superannuation fund with $1,000,000 of Australian blue chip shares in it, and a Federal Politician with a randomly selected salary of $375,588 per annum and the same number of shares. We’ll call him Bill. Let’s ignore Bill’s perks and any other tax breaks – I have never acted for a Federal politician in a tax matter, and frankly I’m happy to keep it that way.
Vince receives fully franked dividends of $50,000 per annum. The way franking credits work is that is cash of $35,000 and franking credits of $15,000. Vince therefore has pension income of $50,000, from which he is exempt from tax. Under the current system the franking credits are refunded to him, so he gets $15,000 from the Federal Govt. This is what the Opposition wants to stop.
Bill on the otherhand is on the top marginal tax rate. He pays lots of tax – if you ignore his fully franked dividend of $50,000 (same as Vince’s) he pays $142,246.60 in tax (before medicare levy). But watch how Bill’s full franked dividend of $50,000 is treated. He gets the same amount of cash - $35,000. But as a result of the franking credit, his tax bill only increases to $149,746.60. If he didn’t get the franking credit, his tax would have been $164,746.60.
In other words, Bill gets the full use of the Franking Credit, because he pays $15,000 less tax than he otherwise would, whereas Vince misses out on the benefit completely. Put in reverse, the Federal coffers pick up $15,000 from Vince, the pensioner on $35k per annum, but don’t get the $15,000 from Bill, the politician on $275,746, after tax.
Not very fair is it?
My good intentions of providing balance must be sacrificed on the altar of brevity. I have already gone on too long. I will criticise the Government in Part 2.
Posted in: Tax & ATO News Australia at 19 March 18
Tom Tate shuns carbon tax
See Channel 9’s news story http://www.nbnnews.com.au/index.php/2012/09/12/tom-tate-shuns-carbon-tax-supporters/
Posted in: Tax & ATO News Australia at 13 September 12
Share

Tax & ATO News Australia
Author: David Hughes
Last 12 months
- January 2021 (0)
- December 2020 (0)
- November 2020 (0)
- October 2020 (0)
- September 2020 (0)
- August 2020 (0)
- July 2020 (0)
- June 2020 (0)
- May 2020 (0)
- April 2020 (0)
- March 2020 (0)
- February 2020 (0)
- Show All
Tags
- Federal Government (2)
- super contributions caps (2)
- resides test (1)
- David Hughes (1)
- Administrative Appears Tribunal (5)
- CGT (3)
- Tax Office (21)
- OECD (1)
- tax evasion (10)
- Part IVA (1)
- concessional contributions (3)
- domicile test (1)
- ATO (58)
- Crown Insurance Services Limited (1)
- small business (9)
- income splitting schemes (1)
- inspector general of taxation (11)
- Double tax agreements (1)
- Commissioner of Taxation (17)
- tax benefit (1)
- non-concessional contributions (2)
- 183 day test (1)
- GST (5)
- Full Federal Court (3)
- decision impact statement (1)
- Office of State Revenue (1)
- Australian National Audit Office (1)
- SNF (1)
- NSW duty (1)
- High Court of Australia (2)
- excess contributions tax (1)
- Crown Insurance Services (2)
- High Court (3)
- Administrative Appeals Tribunal (8)
- Section 264 (1)
- stamp duty (1)
- tax ombudsman (1)
- Division 815 (1)
- Income Tax Regulations (2)
- Goods and Services Tax (2)
- SPAA (1)
- Federal Court (4)
- Tax (27)
- NAB (1)
- Income Tax Assessment 1936 (2)
- land tax (1)
- Federal Assistant Treasurer (2)
- wire tapping (2)
- Joe Hockey (2)
- taxable supply (1)
- SMSF (4)
- bankruptcy notices (1)
- Deportation (2)
- retirement savings (2)
- Taxation Administration Act 1953 (3)
- payroll tax (1)
- Celebrity Tax Evaders (1)
- investigative powers (3)
- Shadow Treasurer (1)
- Assistant Treasurer (2)
- self-managed funds (4)
- bankruptcy regulations (1)
- Transfer duty (1)
- Bill Shorten (3)
- Income tax (6)
- Crown Insurance Limited (1)
- AAT (20)
- Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence (1)
- taxpayers (17)
- cash economy (1)
- s264 notices (2)
- Crown Insurance (1)
- Business assets (1)
- Superannuation Minister (2)
- tax returns (4)
- debt disputes (4)
- taxpayer (9)
- European Union Data Retention Directive (1)
- Parliamentary Committee (1)
- taxman (6)
- Chris Jordan (7)
- taskforce (2)
- Queensland State Government (1)
- Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (4)
- notice of assessment (5)
- debt collection (3)
- Departure Prohibition Order (1)
- superannuation contributions (2)
- Australian resident (2)
- Gary Kurzer (2)
- Tax Commissioner (25)
- tax audit (5)
- audits (3)
- ITAA (3)
- assessment notice (3)
- exchange rate (1)
- carbon tax (1)
- super contributions (3)
- non-resident (2)
- Ron Pattenden (2)
- tax appeals (10)
- discretionary trust partnerships (1)
- heavy handling (2)
- Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (1)
- tax fraud (4)
- foreign currency (1)
- Show All